Lure Compass
Add

Bait & Tackle Shops · Montauk, NY

Bait & Tackle Shops in Montauk

3 listings · ranked by rating & reviews · updated 2026

Bait and tackle shops are the local hub for anglers - the place to grab live and fresh bait, restock terminal tackle, pick up a fishing license and get honest, current intel on what is biting nearby. A good local shop knows the waters better than any app: which spots are producing, what the fish are hitting, and which rig works this week. Many also sell or rent gear, spool reels and point newcomers toward beginner-friendly spots and charters. Hours and stock vary, and live bait can sell out early on a good weekend, so it is worth a call ahead. The listings here help you find nearby shops by city and state, ranked by reviews.

Below are 3 bait & tackle shops listings in Montauk, NY, ranked by Google review volume so you can start with the most established options and contact them directly. The most-reviewed is Westlake Marina (4.7★, 92 Google reviews).

Typical pricing in Montauk

Typical Montauk charter pricing: roughly $600-$1,800 - a half-day inshore trip or party-boat day at the low end, a full-day offshore tuna or shark charter at the top. Party boats price per person; private charters price per boat. Confirm the all-in rate with the operator.

See our full guide to fishing in Montauk for neighborhoods, local pricing and how to choose.

Top bait & tackle shops listings in Montauk

  1. 1
    Westlake Marina
    Charters

    Westlake Marina

    Montauk

    Marina in Montauk, NY · 4.7★ (92).

    ★ 4.7 · 92View →
  2. 2
    Cool Gear Fishing
    Charters

    Cool Gear Fishing

    Montauk

    Bait shop in Montauk, NY · 4.9★ (56).

    ★ 4.9 · 56View →
  3. 3
    North Fork Light Tackle Charters
    Charters

    North Fork Light Tackle Charters

    Montauk

    Fishing charter in Montauk, NY · 5★ (17).

    ★ 5 · 17View →

FAQ

Bait & Tackle Shops in Montauk - common questions

How many bait & tackle shops are there in Montauk? +
Lure Compass lists 3 listings for bait & tackle shops in Montauk, NY.
Who has the best-rated bait & tackle shops in Montauk? +
By Google review volume, Westlake Marina is the most-reviewed bait & tackle shops listing in Montauk (4.7★, 92 reviews). Rankings follow review count, not paid placement.
Can I buy a fishing license at a bait and tackle shop? +
Many bait and tackle shops are authorized to sell state fishing licenses alongside bait and gear, which makes them a convenient one-stop before a trip. Not all shops offer it, so call ahead to confirm - you can also buy a license online through your state wildlife agency.
What do bait and tackle shops sell? +
Typically live and fresh bait, hooks, weights, line, lures, rods and reels, plus local licenses at many shops. Some rent gear or spool reels for you. Stock varies by shop and season, and popular live baits can sell out on busy days, so a quick call ahead is smart.
How do I find a good local tackle shop? +
Browse the shops listed by city and state here and compare Google ratings and review counts. Reviews often mention bait selection, staff knowledge and local advice - the shops locals trust for intel usually stand out. Confirm hours and current stock with the shop before heading over.
How much does a fishing charter cost in Montauk? +
Montauk charters typically run about $600-$1,800 depending on trip and boat - inshore trips and party-boat days at the low end, full-day offshore tuna and shark charters at the top. Confirm the all-in price with the operator.
What is the Montauk fall run? +
In autumn, striped bass and bluefish gather in huge numbers around Montauk Point as they migrate south, creating some of the best surf and boat striper fishing on the East Coast. It is the marquee season - book ahead.
What can you catch out of Montauk? +
Inshore trips target striped bass, bluefish and fluke; offshore trips target tuna, mako shark and sea bass. Seasons matter here, so ask operators what is running for your dates.
Where do Montauk charters depart from? +
Most run from Montauk Harbor and Lake Montauk. The ranked list below covers the area by review volume and rating.

Bait & Tackle Shops in other cities

BiloxiBozemanBrainerdBransonBurlingtonCape CodCape MayCharlestonCharlestonChattanoogaChicagoCoeur d AleneCorpus ChristiDenverDestinDevils LakeErieFarmingtonFort LauderdaleFort MyersGainesvilleGalvestonGuntersvilleJacksonJacksonvilleKailua-KonaKey WestLaconiaLake Havasu CityLake TexomaLas VegasLewesLos AngelesMiamiMichigan CityMilwaukeeMountain HomeMyrtle BeachNaplesNarragansettNew OrleansNewportOcean CityOgallalaOkobojiOld SaybrookOuter BanksPanama City BeachPensacolaPierrePort ClintonPortlandSalt Lake CitySan DiegoSan FranciscoSeattleSoldotnaSomersetTampaTraverse CityVirginia BeachWichita

Other categories in Montauk

Fishing ChartersPublic Fishing SpotsFishing PiersFishing GuidesMarinas & Boat Ramps